How Do Quantitative Easing and Tightening Affect the Federal Budget?
Last Updated May 15, 2023
The Federal Reserve (Fed) plays an important role in stabilizing the country’s economy. The Fed’s main tool to influence economic activity is through adjusting the Federal Funds rate — for example, raising that short-term interest rate to battle high inflation or lowering the rate to incentivize investment. In addition to those actions, the central bank may want to affect long-term rates, which can be carried out by buying or selling government securities and other financial instruments. That approach is known as quantitative easing (QE) or tightening (QT) and is typically implemented when other monetary policy actions are exhausted. Below is an overview of QE and QT, the role they play in monetary policy, and their impact on the federal budget.
Quantitative Easing vs. Quantitative Tightening
In the most basic terms, QE and QT are opposite actions. QE refers to the Fed buying assets to lower longer-term interest rates, and QT means the Fed is selling assets to put upward pressure on longer-term rates.
QE is used when the Fed wants to stimulate the economy and reduce interest rates on longer-term securities. The Fed accomplishes this by purchasing large quantities of Treasury and mortgage-backed securities. Because such purchases can reduce longer-term interest rates and increase liquidity in financial markets, it helps provide economic stimulus. Historically, the Fed has used QE when short-term interest rates are near zero and additional monetary stimulus is needed — such as during a financial crisis or recession. Most recently, the Fed employed QE during the COVID-19 pandemic and grew its securities portfolio from a little under $4.0 trillion in March 2020 to $8.5 trillion by March 2022.
Conversely, QT is used to cool the economy by allowing assets to mature off the central bank’s balance sheet or by selling them. Diminishing the Fed’s portfolio of longer-term debt leads to higher longer-term interest rates than would otherwise be the case, which reduces domestic investment and consumer spending on housing and durable goods. The Fed began implementing QT in the middle of 2022 in an effort to restrain economic activity and tame inflation; such actions are currently reducing the balance sheet by about $60 billion per month.
How Do QE and QT Affect the Federal Budget?
Quantitative easing and tightening affect the federal budget by:
- Influencing the amount of remittances to the Treasury
- Changing net borrowing costs of the U.S. government
- Stimulating aggregate economic activity, and therefore tax revenue
Influencing the Amount of Remittances
The Fed finances much of its activities through interest receipts on the assets it holds, while its expenses largely stem from personnel costs and payment of interest to banks that hold reserves at the Fed. Earnings that the Fed does not need for its activities are remitted to the Treasury and recorded as revenues in the federal budget.
Remittances are generally higher during times of QE and lower during times of QT. Because QE involves the large-scale purchase of securities, and because the Fed has historically made money from interest receipts on the securities that it holds, remittances are higher during those periods. In turn, higher remittances provide larger revenues to the Treasury and help offset the federal deficit. When the Fed utilizes QT, remittances are lower because the central bank lets assets mature off the balance sheet, thereby resulting in smaller interest receipts. Due to the Fed’s use of QT in 2023 and the rapid rise in interest rates, which has made older securities less valuable, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that remittances will only total around $1 billion during the year, compared to $107 billion in 2022.
Changing Net Borrowing Costs of the U.S. Government
The primary channel through which QE affects net borrowing costs is via a reduction in market interest rates (and therefore rates paid on Treasury issuances). If the Fed pushes rates down through the implementation of QE, or pushes rates up through use of QT, such actions affect interest paid on new borrowing, thereby influencing net interest totals in the budget.
Stimulating Economic Activity
Through the reduction of long-term interest rates, QE boosts the economy by reducing the cost of capital and encouraging additional business investment, increasing the demand for homes and other durable goods, and supporting higher domestic consumption as a result of the lower cost of credit. Those changes in the economy can affect federal spending and revenues. One example is that typically during economic downturns, outlays for programs considered automatic stabilizers (such as unemployment insurance, SNAP, and Medicaid) increase as more people become eligible for the federal support. But because QE helps stimulate the economy and mitigate economic downturns, such outlays could be lower than they would be without QE. Moreover, increased economic activity means increased tax revenues for the federal government. QT has a different effect in that the higher interest rates can slow economic growth and boost interest rates, which could reduce revenues and increase outlays.
What Happens to the Federal Budget If the Fed Incurs Losses?
When the Fed used QE and more than doubled its portfolio from 2020 to 2022, it also shifted the composition of the central bank’s balance sheet. In 2020 before the COVID-19 pandemic, 47 percent of the Fed’s liabilities were derived from its distribution of currency, which the Fed did not have to pay interest on; whereas now in 2023, interest-bearing liabilities make up about two-thirds of its total liabilities. At the same time, the bulk of the Fed’s assets are now medium- and long-term securities (Treasury notes and bonds and mortgage-backed-securities). Essentially, the Fed’s balance sheet now consists of more long-term assets that are financed by short-term liabilities, which exposed the Fed to risk when interest rates rose from near-zero in March 2022 to now 4.8 percent.
Those conditions led to probable operating losses for the Fed in 2023. The losses would be considered a “deferred asset” under the Fed’s accounting rules, which means it would not remit anything to the Treasury until it retained earnings that offset its earlier losses. By the Federal Reserve Board’s own baseline estimates, it projects cumulative operating losses of $150 billion through 2025, meaning they would likely remit little or nothing to the Treasury from 2023 to 2025.
Conclusion
The use of quantitative tightening and easing by the Federal Reserve are important tools to help create a healthy economy. QE and QT impact borrowing costs, influence economic activity, and affect the balance sheet and financial position of the Treasury. Particularly as our nation navigates through complex fiscal and economic conditions, it is important to understand the critical role that monetary policy plays for our budget, deficit, and economic future.
Image credit: Photo by Win McNamee/Staff
Further Reading
What Is the Disaster Relief Fund?
Climate and weather-related natural disasters are becoming increasingly frequent. In addition to endangering lives, they are economically costly.
How Does the Aging of the Population Affect Our Fiscal Health?
As a large portion of the American population lives well beyond retirement age, the total cost of providing healthcare will grow as well.
What Is the Farm Bill, and Why Does It Matter for the Federal Budget?
The Farm Bill provides an opportunity for policymakers to comprehensively address agricultural, food, conservation, and other issues.