New analysis released today from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) shows deficits doubling and debt skyrocketing under a scenario where the expiring provisions of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) were made permanent. If interest rates were also higher than projected, a second scenario shows that the United States would incur even worse fiscal damage.
CBO finds that:
- If provisions of the TCJA were made permanent (and there were no other changes to fiscal policy), debt held by the public (DHBP) would reach 214 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) in 2054 — 47 percentage points higher than under the baseline scenario in which the provisions expire as scheduled and well above the level in 2024 of 98 percent of GDP.
- Making those provisions permanent would lead to a near-doubling of the annual deficit relative to GDP — from 6.3 percent this year to 12.3 percent in 2054.
- In addition, if interest rates also increased each year until they were higher than projected by 1 percentage point, DHBP would exceed 250 percent of GDP within 30 years. Macroeconomic feedback effects would further increase interest rates and, therefore, lead to even worse fiscal outcomes. Such findings demonstrate the sensitivity of the nation’s finances to borrowing costs.
As lawmakers consider the expiring tax provisions this year, they should keep in mind the effects on the nation’s unsustainable debt, and follow guiding principles for fiscally responsible tax policy.
Further Reading
Growing National Debt Sets Off Alarm Bells for U.S. Business Leaders
Debt rising unsustainably threatens the country’s economic future, and a number of business leaders have signaled their concern.
What Is R Versus G and Why Does It Matter for the National Debt?
The combination of higher debt levels and elevated interest rates have increased the cost of federal borrowing, prompting economists to consider the sustainability of our fiscal trajectory.
High Interest Rates Left Their Mark on the Budget
When rates increase, borrowing costs rise; unfortunately, for the fiscal bottom line, that dynamic has been playing out over the past few years.